I think we can call the vets vs newbs experiment a failure.

Does anyone think anybody but Roy, Laura, Tate and Miranda have any chance at making the final three? Really this season has played out almost exactly according to form, with the best vets dominating. There have been only two surprises- Miranda is a lot better than I would have expected and RJ showed nothing all season.

The newbs have sucked. Shockingly the best newb is Laney, whiney voice and all. And it's not like she's really good. Scott + Eddie are consistently weak and look to be gone soon. So the newbs basically have nothing.