GaryP11111 wrote:

As I said, I disagree with my friend's assessment. But even if I knew Tim only through his writings I would not use this episode to diminish him. I think he's earned that. And sure, I understand some people are disappointed with Tim's position. But I DO know Tim. I AM aware of his overall contributions to the genre. I know what kind of human being he is and I know what kind of editor he is (I've had the honor and pleasure to write for Video Watchdog)...I do not believe Tim's stance justifies attacks that seem to aspire to instantly nullify a brilliant reputation and decades' worth of achievement. Writers and publishers are upset about the recent revelations of plagiarism and they have a right to be. But people need to watch out for collatoral damage and people should try to avoid acting like a bevy of tricoteuses sitting around the guillotine.
I heartily agree. When accusations appear against someone's friend or colleague, I would naturally expect that friend or colleague to be cautious and generous of spirit. Because they know that person, and I don't. Tim adjusted his stance after learning more about the facts and scope of the situation. 

I'm always suspicious of those who instantly and strongly feel a need to gloat, condemn and to punish.

I've had the pleasure of Tim's company on a handful of occasions. He is rational, intelligent, compassionate and empathetic. I admire him for more than his talent. I trust him because he is trusting. 



Meet me here: https://www.facebook.com/max.drunkenseveredhead