Phibes by a mile. See the problem is from what we see of Edward Lionheart he IS a ham actor. So I have no problem with critics calling him as such. The film is very mean spirited IMO whereas Phibes is a lot more fun, and the villain far more interesting and bizarre. I think it's better directed as well, and despite Theater's collection of grand British stage actors, prefer the performances in Phibes as well.