I agree 100% about the 4 judges. But I am not too sure who I would take, Kara or Paula. Paula is annoying, but her apparent drunkeness is usually good for a chuckle, and watching Simon laugh at her is always great for a laugh. But Kara seems to know a bit more about music than Paula, but her arrogance annoys the living snot out of me. I think I would be happy with just Randy and Simon, who both seem to get along with each other.

My fanzine all about Rock N Roll: http://sonicruin.blogspot.com